Friday, May 9, 2014

CAPITAL PUNISHMENT - LEGALIZED REVENGE

Capital Punishment

History:
1.       Stoning                                          100% efficient
2.       Burning at the stake                   100% efficient
3.       Beheading
a.       Axe, etc                       100% efficient
b.      Guillotine                     100% efficient
4.       Hanging                                        100% efficient
5.       Firing Squad + Coup de Grâce      100% efficient
6.       Electric chair                                    +/- efficient…some complications
7.       Lethal injection                                 +/- efficient…some complications
Bible – God spared Cain.  Mosaic Law and developments = Pro
Catholic Church – Evolving from Pro to Con, with some allowance for Pro
Present countries - 56 countries, including the United States = Pro
States within the United States that have abolished capital punishment = 18


Humane?
The greatest single OXYMORON you’ll ever hear: “Humane capital punishment.”
I ask you: “Is capital punishment beneficent, benevolent, benignant, compassionate, good-hearted, kind, kindhearted, kindly, softhearted, sympathetic, tender, tenderhearted, warmhearted?
It is related to attentive, considerate, solicitous, thoughtful; affable, amicable, benign, companionable, comradely, cordial, friendly, genial, gentle, good, good-natured, good-tempered, gracious, mild, neighborly, nice, pleasant, sweet, warm; clement, forbearing, forgiving, lenient, merciful, soft; patient, pitying, tolerant, understanding; altruistic, brotherly, charitable, freehanded, generous, greathearted, humanitarian, liberal, magnanimous, munificent, noble, openhearted, selfless, unselfish, unsparing; anticruelty, cruelty-free?

Clayton Lockett? 
May this name never disappear from the American consciousness.  This could be the name that brings some sanity into the collective soul of this country.  I pray that it will.
This is a man who was cruelly victimized by incompetent government officials of the state of Oklahoma, USA.  They planned to kill him with a cocktail of three drugs and they failed.  They stopped the procedure and the ill-fated human being in their “care” died from a massive heart attack, no doubt caused by their bumbling ignorance.  Remorse?  Of course not.  He deserved to die anyway since he himself had killed and tortured his victim too, 15 years before. [Paraphrase of statements made by two state officials and other opiners]

That’s the “pro” side of the story.  The “con” side says that the executioners should have remorse since they did not treat the victim “humanely.”  WhAaat??  It’s OK to kill people provided you do it humanely?  They don’t make insane asylums big enough, high enough nor wide enough to hold that many deranged humans at one time. Kill someone humanely?  Now ain’t that a concept?

Actually, the more humane you get at this exercise in human malevolence, the less efficient you become.  Can any of you imagine how irreversibly and invincibly ignorant a population can be that in the 21st century it has a difficulty in killing a human being?  I’ll be that it didn’t take Cain 45 minutes to kill Abel.  I’ll bet that it didn’t take 45 minutes for adulteresses to die from stoning in Old Testament days.  We know for sure that the guillotine and the firing squad are a lot more efficient and less painless than suffering from intravenous torture for 45 minutes before dying. 

One of the reasons that we still are one of the few first world countries with the death penalty is that we are still trying to figure how to kill a fellow human humanelyAt this rate, who knows how long it will take us.  Given our ferocious alligator jaw grip on our “American Exceptionalism Arrogance” it will be a long time before we are willing to accept that we are so retrograde that we don’t even know how to kill a person quickly.  Our European counterparts have given up trying to civilize us into abolishing the use of deadly force as a punishment.  They refuse to sell us the drugs of our choice required, we think, to kill people humanely.  We therefore have graduated to an even more barbaric level of human behavior by experimenting with other methods of slaughtering our fellow human beings by using human beings for the experimentation.  Isn't this a great country to live in?  Doesn't this just make you shirt button bustin’ proud to be an American? 
It is just simply frustrating to me to have to be counted as belonging to a civilization of such a low level of human development.  Imagine having to admit that I am among people who won’t abolish the death penalty and yet refuse to use methods of killing people that really, infallibly, with 100% zero failure rate certainty, work?  It’s embarrassing, you know.

I have a proposition for you primates out there.  It is an either / or suggestion.
If you insist on punishing people by killing them, use one of these three methods:
1.      1. Guillotine (There are many of them in museums.  You can rent one as needed)
2.      2. Firing squad with coup-de-grace (Wayne LaPierre can help you here)
3.     3.  Hanging (If you can find someone to sell you the rope)

Or, you can hoist yourselves up by the 21st century boot straps, civilize yourselves and stop killing people out of revenge.  Yep, I said revenge.  It sure as shooting (oops, sorry, Wayne) ain’t justice.  Killing the killer doesn't fix anything.  It diminishes the “punish-er” and frees the killer.  The same rage that it took the original killer is what drives the punishing killer.  The punishing killer who acts in representation of the community damages the community by lowering it to the animal level of the original killer.  Killing the killer isn't really punishment.  Actually, it is release.  It is freedom gained.  It is more a reward than a punishment, you know.  The real punishment is the lack of freedom.  The permanent Lockup that assures the killer that there will never be any freedom available is real punishment.  The permanence of the cage is more punishing than the release of death. 
Furthermore, the killing of a human being in the name of the community imprisons the direct perpetrators of the deed, the surviving members of the families of the two people who have died, and it imprisons the entire population with memories that can never be shaken loose. 

In closing, I will just say this.  I am a very religious person.  In fact I am a very dedicated Catholic.  I am saying this because I want you to know that Capital Punishment is not a purely religious issue.  It is a basic human issue.  I say with neither fear of error nor compunction, The practice of Capital Punishment makes us all less human.  Yes, I said ALL.

No comments:

Post a Comment